Updated :: 6 May ’11
We have started a search for the best cinnamon roll in Portland. We found after today we have some work ahead of us.
Here’s how it came about. My friend Wendy sent out an email to me and another friend, Rose, and said we needed to hit a few shops and rate cinnamon rolls. She had me at “cinnamon roll.”
Wendy loves cinnamon rolls and tries them at most places. Rose and I also consider ourselves connoisseurs as well and try them all over the place. But Rose and I also like roller coasters so we have dubbed ourselves Cinnamon ROLLercoaster Taster Testers. Yep, that would be our perfect job description.
Since we were going after our workout class, we decided to make some calls before we made the drive all the way out to N. Portland to make sure they still had some. We called both shops and had them set 2 aside for us. Jim and Patty’s only had 2 left, so glad we (meaning Wendy) thought ahead.
Fleur De Lis had the most write ups, so we decided to go there last, you know so we could end on a high note.
JIM & PATTY’S
4951 Northeast Fremont Street
Portland, OR 97213
Jim & Patty’s Coffee
They are known for their coffee cake, but we had also read that the cinnamon rolls were some of the best in Portland. We got there and were greeted by a bustling coffee shop with tons of great pastries. Luckily we had called ahead and there in the back sat our 2 huge cinnamon rolls.
We all agreed and ordered them slightly heated.
The bread was good and even the outside layer was moist. That’s a plus. The inside had hazelnuts, which we had not seen, but I thoroughly enjoyed.
The cinnamon sugar mixture had big chunks of sugar. I didn’t like the texture and Rose agreed. Wendy thought it was fine, but understood what we were talking about. Rose and I both docked points for that.
Overall we gave this cinnamon roll an 8 out of 10. I gave it a 7, but they rated it a bit higher, averaging out to 8.
I didn’t see the tea, but the coffee was Stumptown.
FLEUR DE LIS
3930 NE Hancock St
Portland, OR 97212
Fleur De Lis
Keep in mind we were doing our tasting during lunch hour. The soups looked great at this place, but we stayed focused.
We had also called ahead and had 2 set aside here as well, just in case someone else was having a hankering for cinnamon rolls or doing a taste test.
Our initial response was they were dry. Really dry. I even dug right into the gooey middle and it too was dry.
There were no nuts, it wasn’t overly saucey and thankfully it didn’t have chunks of sugar, but it was not that good. We all agreed it was a disappointment considering it had the most reviews.
We gave this one a 4 I think. Correct me girls if I am wrong.
There was plenty of other things that looked fantastic at this place, so don’t shy away, just don’t show up expecting the best cinnamon roll in Portland or you will be disappointed. So much for ending on a high note.
They served a Firefox Tea, which is a Portland Co. It was great!! They also serve Stumptown Coffee.
Even though we had more places to try we were too full to pursue another tasting, so our search continues…
March 6, 2011 Update
Fat City Cafe
7820 Southwest Capitol Highway
Portland, Oregon 97219
Fat City Cafe
I think at this point I could honestly stop looking for the best Cinnamon Roll in Portland because I think I finally found it. It only took me 3 tries, but this is the perfect cinnamon roll. It’s large, it’s gooey on the outside and there were no chunks of sugar, just perfectly covered with the right amount of cinnamon and sugar. Nothing about it was over the top. It is also perfectly priced at just $2.25. I brought half of mine home and it was not even disappointing the next day. Still so gooey.
But, that does not mean I am going to stop looking, that doesn’t mean I won’t try another. That means that all other cinnamon rolls will now be compared to the Fat City’s Cinnamon Roll.